MINUTES
ADVISORY
NEIGHBORHOOD COMMISSION 3F
NORTH
CLEVELAND PARK / FOREST HILLS
PUBLIC
MEETING
Washington
Home & Hospice Center
3720
Upton Street, NW
Washington,
D.C. 20016
July
30, 2001
1.CALL
TO ORDER
Chair
Bardin called the meeting to order at 7:33 pm. Commissioners Kogan, Perry,
Mitchell and Oglesby were present. With five of the seven commissioners,
Chair Bardin declared a quorum. Chair Bardin stated that Commissioner Maudlin
had given Commissioner Kogan his proxy.
2.AGENDA
The
tentative agenda was approved by consensus, subject to moving the Delhi
Dhaba liquor license up ahead of redistricting and the possibility of moving
up the playground matter. The Treasurer's monthly report for July was stricken
since July was not over.
3.MINUTES
Minutes
of the July 9, 2001, meeting were approved, subject to four typographical
corrections, 5-0-0, on motion of Commissioner Oglesby seconded by Commissioner
Perry.
4.ANNOUNCEMENTS
/ OPEN FORUM
There
were no announcements or Open Forum items.
5.POLICE
REPORT
No
representative of the Second District of the Metropolitan Police Department
was present.
6.FOUR
MORE HOSPICE BEDS AT WASHINGTON HOME
Linda
Grigsby introduced Washington Home Executive Director, Lynn Collins O'Connor,
who explained that the present issue is the application to the State Healthcare
Planning and Development Agency (SHPDA) in the DC Department of Health
for a Certificate of Need (CON) for an additional four hospice beds (over
and above the existing nine hospice beds). She also related forthcoming
issues, including construction of an addition to house the four additional
beds and reconfiguration of the parking lot, that will be presented for
ANC review at a later date, when the Washington Home seeks approval from
the Board of Zoning Adjustment (BZA). The Home's architect, Laurie D. Dickeson,
RA (of Amos Bailey Arnold + Associates, Inc.) gave a preview of those issues
for the sake of greater clarity and understanding. They also introduced
consulting arborist Jerry Dieruf and Medical Director, Dr. Matthew Kestenbaum,
in the course of answering questions from the commissioners and the community.
A.
Ms. O'Connor said that the Washington Home, established in 1888, rebuilt
its facility on Upton Street in 1985 with ANC support. It is the only present
supplier of inpatient hospice beds in Washington, DC. (Most of the hospice
patients at any given time live at home, with outpatient hospice support
and expectation that inpatient care could be had in case of severe pain
management or like issues. Inpatient care is intended for patients with
less than a 6-month life expectancy and the average length of stay for
inpatients is 7 - 8 days.) The four-bed increment proposal for the CON
is based on a market study by Corridor Group, described as a nationally-recognized
firm.
B.
A forthcoming proposal to increase the number of parking spaces (from to
, and increase of 131% with only a 7% increase in the area devoted to parking)
reflects judgments as to the general needs of the Washington Home – and
is only very slightly influenced by limited added use due to the four hospice
beds. The parking plan would cut into the existing berm without lowering
the berm top. Commissioner Oglesby alerted the Washington Home of her interest
in measures to encourage employees to use Metro and Executive Director
O'Connor stated that the Home is going to examine options for expanding
employee use of Metro.
C.
The SHPDA [Question #73] asks the applicant about ANC support for a CON.
On motion of Commissioner Kogan, seconded by Commissioner Perry, the ANC
unanimously adopted a resolution supporting the CON application, 6-0-0
(Commissioner Kogan voting Commissioner Maudlin's proxy). (Copy of Res
01-18 attached)
7.FOREST
HILLS PLAYGROUND
David
Von Drehle, a member of the Board of the Friends of Forest Hills Playground,
Inc. (Friends), explained that an anonymous donor has made possible additional
work to enhance the playground, including retention of landscape architect
James Urban, whom he introduced. Mr. Urban described plans for supplementing
entry stairs on Chesapeake Street with a ramp (giving stroller and ADA
access), sandbox renovations (including wooden edging to hold in new sand
and be suitable for sitting), replacement of dead, dying and unhealthy
shade trees, erosion control, improving the community bulletin board (with
better roofing and easier access for posting), planting ornamental trees,
new fencing and gating and a walk paved with donor-name-inscribed bricks.
Mr. Neal Rodgers, Chief of Staff to Department of Parks & Recreation
Director Neil O. Albert, explained the positive stance of the Department.
He and Mr. Urban answered questions from commissioners and the community.
Also present were Friends President, Laura Cira, and Vice-President, Karen
Ball.
On
motion of Commissioner Bardin, seconded by Commissioner Oglesby, the ANC
approved a letter to Director Neil O. Albert of the DC Department of Parks
& Recreation, requesting early action on the proposal. 6-0-0 (Commissioner
Kogan voting Commissioner Maudlin's proxy). (Copy of Ltr 01-02 attached)
8.DELHI
DHABA RESTAURANT, 4455 CONNECTICUT AVENUE
Fred
Dumere described the replacement for the former Boston Market as a family
restaurant, specializing in northern Indian food, like that he has operated
since 1993 at 7236 Woodmont Avenue in Bethesda. There will be free parking
after office hours and underground parking during the day with a validation
stamp from the restaurant.
On
motion of Commissioner Perry, seconded by Commissioner Oglesby, the ANC
approved, 5-0-0, the attached Voluntary Agreement prepared by Commissioner
Perry in consultation with the Applicant and endorsed by Mr. Dumere during
the meeting. Commissioner Perry will fill in the ABC Board Application
Number when received and the Chair was authorized to respond to the ABC
Board inquiry.
9.OPTIONS
FOR ANC REDISTRICTING
Commissioner
Bardin summarized the process and timetable for redistricting single-member
districts of ANC commissioners and for deciding on changes in ANC boundaries,
culminating in legislation by the DC Council. An extensive discussion of
options engaged some of the commissioners and the following residents in
or near ANC 3F in questions, comments and expressions of concern:
-
Phil Barringer, east side of 38th Street (betw. Chesapeake & Brandywine)
–
Kay McClennon, 3700 Albemarle, who served on 1991 redistricting committee
–
Gary Steven, 3100 Chesapeake Street
-
Richard Abbott, 4305 38th Street (betw. Windom & Yuma)
–
George Clark, 4525 28th Street
–
John Richotte, 37th Street (betw. Warren & Windom)
–
Mary Alice Levine, 3800 block of Albemarle
-
Cheryl Browning, 4426 Grant Road
–
Matt Pavuk, 4426 Grant Road
-
Marvin Tievsky, 3810 Warren Street
The
question may come up for a resolution at the ANC's September 10 meeting.
10.ADJOURNMENT
On
motion of Commissioner Kogan, seconded by Commissioner Perry, the ANC adjourned,
5-0-0. The next meeting will be on September 10, 2001, at a location to
be announced.
Respectfully
submitted,
David
J. Bardin